48 Hours in Sheridan: The Local Favorites Itinerary

Your insider's guide to Sheridan, Wyoming. This 48-hour itinerary skips the tourist traps and takes you where Sheridan locals actually eat, drink, and spend their time—all walkable from The Main Exchange.

---

Hosted by The Main Exchange

Boutique lodging in downtown Sheridan, WY

Managed by Wyo Stays, a Sheridan brokerage with 300+ five-star Google reviews across its portfolio

---

Day 1: Arrival & Neighborhood Exploration

Day 1 – Morning: Local Coffee & Hidden Gems

8:00 AM — Check into The Onyx and drop your bags. The 2,200 sq ft suite is your home base for a locals-only weekend.

8:30 AM — Walk to The Grounds (155 N Main St, easy to miss—look for the alley entrance). Small-batch roasting on-site, best pour-over in Sheridan, no tourist crowds.

9:30 AM — Stroll Main Street like a local. Skip the obvious spots and explore:

• Cottonwood Kitchen (artisan pantry goods, Wyoming-made products)
• The Loom Room (Montana textiles, handcrafted goods)
• Big Horn Foods (local grocery, Wyoming beef, craft sodas)

10:30 AM — Walk the Tongue River Island Trail (behind County Courthouse, park on Brooks Street). 2-mile paved loop along the river—locals walk dogs and jog here. Peaceful even at midday.

Locals Know: The Grounds only opens Mon–Fri, 7 AM–2 PM. If you're visiting on weekends, hit Java Moon instead and ask for the house blend (not the tourist drip).

Day 1 – Afternoon: Lunch & Art Walk

12:00 PM — Lunch at The Busy Bean (46 S Main St, across from the post office). Unchanged since 1985, massive pancakes, $8 breakfast platters. Locals-only vibe, zero tourists.

1:30 PM — Visit The Brinton Museum (12 minutes from downtown). Locals know to skip the crowds and visit on weekday afternoons. Sculpture gardens, Western art, historic ranch house.

3:30 PM — Return downtown and explore King's Saddlery (working saddle shop since 1946, custom leather goods). Chat with the craftspeople—they're happy to explain the saddle-making process.

5:00 PM — Head back to The Onyx to rest before an evening at local haunts.

Ask Concierge to Arrange This: Our AI Concierge can recommend seasonal events, farmers markets, and neighborhood pop-ups that tourists miss. Get insider tips here.

Day 1 – Evening: Neighborhood Bars & Local Eats

6:00 PM — Dinner at Public House (farm-to-table, Wyoming-raised beef). Locals come for happy hour (3–6 PM weekdays) and stay for the seasonal menu.

7:30 PM — Walk to The Mint Bar (151 N Main St, Wyoming's oldest bar since 1907). Skip the tourist photo ops and head to the back bar for pool tables, shuffleboard, and actual conversation.

9:00 PM — If you're feeling adventurous, drive to Suds 'N Suds (242 Coffeen Ave)—a functioning laundromat with a full bar attached. Yes, seriously. Locals love it for the novelty and cheap drinks.

10:30 PM — Return to The Onyx. Open a local craft beer from Black Tooth Brewing (pick up a six-pack earlier) and relax by the fireplace.

Day 2: Deep Local Dive & Hidden Trails

Day 2 – Morning: Diner Breakfast & Secret Trails

7:30 AM — Breakfast at The Busy Bean (if you skipped it yesterday) or prep your own at The Onyx's chef's kitchen using ingredients from Big Horn Foods.

9:00 AM — Drive 15 minutes to Red Grade Trail (locals-only hiking spot, no signs, no crowds). Park on the shoulder and follow the worn trailhead. 6-mile loop, wildflowers, aspen groves.

12:00 PM — Pack a picnic from The Onyx and eat on the trail. Locals bring thermoses of coffee and homemade sandwiches.

Locals Know: Red Grade Trail sees zero tourists. Bring bear spray (black bears in summer) and don't expect cell service. It's a locals-only secret.

Day 2 – Afternoon: Return & Main Street Wind-Down

2:00 PM — Late lunch at Black Tooth Brewing (local brewery, pizza, burgers). Sit on the patio and order the Bomber Mountain Amber—it's what locals drink.

3:30 PM — Walk Main Street one more time. Visit spots you missed:

• The Brinton Museum Gift Shop (Western art prints, handcrafted jewelry)
• King's Saddlery (custom leather, working saddle shop)
• Cottonwood Kitchen (grab Wyoming-made pantry goods to take home)

5:00 PM — Return to The Onyx for a rest and final evening preparation.

Day 2 – Evening: Final Night Like a Local

6:30 PM — Dinner at Frackelton's or Wyld (reserve ahead). Order whatever the chef recommends—locals trust the seasonal menu.

8:00 PM — Check the WYO Theater calendar for live music, film screenings, or local theater. Sheridan locals support the arts—it's a community hub, not just a tourist attraction.

9:30 PM — Final nightcap at The Mint Bar or back at The Onyx. Reflect on your locals-only weekend and plan your next Sheridan visit.

Key Takeaways: Your Local Favorites 48 Hours

1. Stay at The Onyx — Locals appreciate the design, full kitchen, and Main Street walkability
2. Ask locals for recommendations — Sheridan residents are friendly and love sharing hidden spots
3. Skip the tourist traps — The best experiences are often unmarked (Red Grade Trail, The Grounds, Suds 'N Suds)
4. Support local businesses — King's Saddlery, Cottonwood Kitchen, and Black Tooth Brewing are locally owned and operated

Where to Stay: The Main Exchange

For a locals-approved base with chef's kitchen, boutique design, and Main Street access, The Onyx (Suite 201) delivers 2,200 sq ft of curated comfort.

Moving to Sheridan? The Aspen (Suite 202) offers Executive Stays — 30 nights or longer, month-to-month — with private garage, in-home sauna, and neighborhood integration for new residents.

---

Ready to explore Sheridan like a local? Use our AI Concierge to discover seasonal events, neighborhood pop-ups, and hidden gems based on your travel dates.

➕ Add This Itinerary to Your Trip

Visit our AI Trip Planner to customize this local favorites itinerary with real-time recommendations, seasonal events, and insider tips from Sheridan residents.

Plan My Stay · Book The Onyx · Explore The Aspen